Back to Product Catalog: Take Orders Blog

Shopify Starter vs. Big Cartel: Which Is Better for Link Selling?

P
Product Catalog: Take Orders
7 min read

Shopify Starter provides a focused checkout flow designed for social media links, whereas Big Cartel provides a standard storefront designed for independent creators with compact inventories. For sellers who distribute items primarily through direct links on Instagram, WhatsApp, or bio pages rather than managing an extensive website, Shopify Starter offers a more direct path to checkout. However, both services require setup steps and payment constraints that simple link catalogs bypass.

The Mechanics of Link Selling

Link selling involves distributing a single URL or QR code across social channels, messaging apps, or bio links to collect orders without routing buyers through a multi-page site. Mobile shoppers browsing social platforms prioritize speed. Extra checkout friction—such as account creation or extensive forms—often leads to abandoned orders.

Assessing tools for link-based commerce requires evaluating how readily a customer can transition from tapping a link to completing an order. Shopify Starter and Big Cartel approach this process differently, with distinct cost structures, ordering flows, and payment configurations.

Takeaway: Direct link selling depends on clear product listings and a direct checkout flow that minimizes steps for mobile buyers.

Shopify Starter: Streamlined Links with Ongoing Transaction Fees

Shopify Starter replaces full storefront design with product cards and direct purchase links. Instead of building multi-page layouts, you enter product photos, descriptions, and prices, then share the generated URLs across social profiles or chat messages. Shoppers who open the link view a product page and complete payment using card processors.

While this approach suits link distribution, it introduces ongoing costs. Shopify Starter charges a monthly subscription alongside a 5% transaction fee on sales processed through its native checkout. Additionally, the setup relies on card processing, which does not accommodate sellers who use cash on delivery or manually review orders before allocating inventory.

Key Features of Shopify Starter

  • Generates direct product links for social profiles and messaging channels.
  • Uses Shopify's standard payment processing and basic sales reporting.
  • Requires a monthly subscription fee plus a 5% transaction fee per order.
  • Requires buyers to complete orders through digital card payment gateways.

Takeaway: Shopify Starter works well for sellers who require automated card processing and are comfortable paying monthly and per-transaction fees in exchange for minimal page setup.

Big Cartel: Free Entry Tier with Multi-Page Storefront Navigation

Big Cartel caters to independent makers and artists by offering a straightforward online store builder with a no-cost entry tier. You can list up to five products without monthly subscription fees or platform commissions. However, Big Cartel is structured as a conventional online store rather than a direct-link purchase tool.

Links shared from Big Cartel direct visitors to a storefront rather than a single-item ordering portal. While suitable for browsing a seasonal collection, this model adds navigation steps for buyers arriving from a specific post or conversation. Furthermore, listing more than five items requires a paid plan, and processing payments requires linking third-party accounts such as Stripe or PayPal.

Key Features of Big Cartel

  • Offers a free plan for up to five product listings with no platform transaction commissions.
  • Features a standard storefront format with customizable themes.
  • Directs buyers through store browsing rather than a single-item quick-order flow.
  • Requires third-party payment accounts like Stripe or PayPal for processing.

Takeaway: Big Cartel suits creators who want a free visual storefront, but its multi-step navigation requires extra effort from direct-link buyers.

Comparison: Link Usability, Friction, and Cost Structure

Comparing Shopify Starter and Big Cartel illustrates the trade-off between direct link checkout and traditional catalog browsing across common operational criteria:

  • Setup Process: Shopify Starter requires minimal visual configuration because it uses standardized product cards. Big Cartel requires theme selection and store section setup.
  • Buyer Journey: Shopify Starter sends buyers directly to a product checkout card. Big Cartel directs buyers to a broader shop layout where items must be added to a cart before checkout.
  • Pricing: Big Cartel has a free plan for up to five products. Shopify Starter charges a recurring monthly fee alongside a 5% transaction fee.
  • Payment Options: Both platforms center on credit card processing and merchant accounts, offering minimal built-in support for cash on delivery or manual order approval.

Takeaway: For card-based checkouts from individual links, Shopify Starter offers a more direct mobile experience than Big Cartel, despite ongoing transaction fees.

The Alternative: Direct Ordering Without Online Payment Gateways

For local sellers and independent businesses operating via WhatsApp, Instagram, or local pickups, merchant gateway setups and customer account requirements can add friction. Transactions conducted through direct messaging often run more efficiently on a simple order-and-fulfill model: customers browse, select items, and pay upon delivery.

Using a dedicated catalog tool such as Product Catalog: Take Orders provides this workflow. You can set up a catalog in minutes by adding a photo, price, and description for each product, then share a single link or QR code via chat apps and social profiles. Customers view the catalog in a standard mobile browser without downloading an app or creating an account, select items, and place their order.

Orders go directly to your inbox, where you confirm or reject each request, and customers pay with cash on delivery. This approach removes payment gateway configuration and per-transaction platform deductions. The free tier supports up to 10 published products, and a monthly subscription removes the listing limit as your inventory grows.

Takeaway: For local sales and direct communication channels, using a catalog link with cash on delivery removes gateway fees and lets customers order without registering.

Checklist: Choosing the Right Link-Selling Strategy

Use these points to evaluate which ordering method matches your catalog size, payment practices, and fulfillment process:

  1. Evaluate Your Payment Method: If you require automated online card collection, choose an option with integrated processing such as Shopify Starter. If you collect payment on delivery, select a tool that does not mandate gateway integrations.
  2. Review Your Catalog Size: For five or fewer items on a zero-cost budget, Big Cartel's free tier covers storefront basics. For up to 10 items shared via direct links with cash on delivery, a dedicated catalog link is more direct.
  3. Assess Checkout Friction: Determine whether your customers prefer quick order entry or standard ecommerce carts. If account creation or lengthy forms slow sales in chat channels, switch to an account-free mobile catalog.
  4. Calculate Ongoing Costs: Total your platform subscription fees alongside percentage transaction cuts before selecting a selling tool.

Takeaway: Choose selling tools that mirror how your customers order and settle payment, rather than paying for features outside your workflow.

Conclusion

Between Shopify Starter and Big Cartel, Shopify Starter is the more direct choice for link selling due to its mobile product cards. Big Cartel provides a dependable free option for artists who want a conventional storefront layout. However, for merchants who sell through direct messages, accept cash on delivery, and want an ordering process free of customer logins, sharing a direct catalog link offers an efficient way to convert social inquiries into confirmed orders.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Shopify Starter better than Big Cartel for social media links?

Yes. Shopify Starter is designed for direct product links, leading buyers directly to a product checkout card rather than through a traditional storefront layout.

Can you use Big Cartel for link selling for free?

Big Cartel offers a free plan for up to five products, but it directs visitors to a standard storefront layout with cart steps rather than a single-link quick-order page.

How does cash on delivery work with link selling?

While platforms like Shopify Starter and Big Cartel rely on digital payment processors, direct catalog tools allow customers to submit orders directly to a merchant's inbox for confirmation, with payment collected in cash upon delivery.

Product Catalog: Take Orders
Get Product Catalog: Take Orders
See download options
Install